Wine Group Tasting Report

It's the heart of Summer and there are less calls for the big red wine or very much else at all. Considering that most folk out there are away on vacation albeit not too far away due to price of gas, traffic is a little slow. (Thank you OPEC) Needless to say the month had started to get monotonous.

So much so that it was nice to have been summoned for a 40 minute drive to HQ for a Wine Consultant tasting.(Even with gas at $4.00 a gallon) The last few WC meetings had been very informative and the new big wigs were pulling more interesting wine. This one was no different.

We covered an interesting array of estate grown German Riesling, Grand Cru Alsace, Italians from Piedmont and marvelous Rhones to name some.

Listed below are my tasting notes for the Tasting at HQ (For details of my tasting method please see the bottom of the page)* :

Selbach Oster Mosel-Saar-Ruwer Riesling Kabinett 2007
Nose- 7.5
Taste- 8
Body - 6
Tanin/Acidity - 8
Finish- 8
Integration : Flowery and white peach appear elgantly on the nose leading to a palate of crystalized citrus fruits and touches of honey. Medium bodied with a bright acidity balance and it finishes with 30 seconds elegantly and shifts time. Best from 2008-2011. Price US$20-US$25
Total: 87.5 points

Selbach Oster Mosel-Saar-Ruwer Zeltinger Himmerreich Riesling Kabinett
Halbtrocken 2007
Nose- 8.5
Taste- 8
Body - 7
Tanin/Acidity - 9
Finish- 9
Intergration: A good whiff of bees wax and honeyed apricots nose leading to a clean crisp palate of honeycombs, ripe peach in a medium to full bodied frame. The fruit and acid balance is almost laserlike and the wine finishes with a clean display of citrus fruits going on for 35 seconds. The wine overall has a restrained elegance due to its youth and should merit some cellaring to fully blossom. Best from 2010- 2020. Price US$23-US$28.
Total points: 91.5

Domaine Albert Boxler Pinot Blanc Reserve Alsace 2005
Nose- 8
Taste- 8
Body - 7
Tanin/Acidity - 8
Finish- 7
Intergration: The nose throws you earthen flower notes sprinkled with exotic spices. The palate opens up with citrus fruits and honeyed peaches. Balances well, going easy on the acidity giving the impression of a fleshier frame for its body. The finish is 30 seconds long and clean with mineral notes. Very harmonious drink. (+1)
Best from 2008- 2012. Price US$30-US$34.
Total points: 87 points

Domaine Albert Riesling Grand Cru Sommerberg Alsace 2004
Nose- 8
Taste- 9
Body - 9
Tanin/Acidity - 7
Finish- 8
Integration: Spring honeycombs and spicy nectarines greet the nose. The full-bodied, unctuous palate is layered with young pineapple, bees wax and hints of glycerin. The finish is clean and 35 seconds long. (+2)
Best from 2009- 2020. Price US$57-US$62.
Total points: 92

Domaine Boyer-Martenot Meursault Charmes 2006
Nose- 9
Taste- 8.5
Body - 8
Tanin/Acidity - 8.5
Finish- 9
Integration: Tropical fruit mingle with apricots and toasted nuts jump from the glass. The seamless lead to mineral laced ripe fruit and citrus oils work wonders with a laser-like balance in acidity. It is elegantly full bodied and drives down confidently to a 40 second finish that shifts time making the experience wanting for the next sip. A great effort.
Best from 2008-2018. Price US$82-US$88
Total points: 93

Luli Chardonnay Santa Lucia Highlands 2007
Nose- 7.5
Taste- 7
Body - 7
Tanin/Acidity - 8
Finish- 8
Integration: Ripe tropical fruit and red skin apples with a dash of nutmeg leads to a honeyed fruit laden mid with a tiny hint of stony minerals. Zesty acidity keep this wine lively as the medium to full bodied frame glides to a 35 second finish.
Best from 2008-2011. Price US$18-US$22
Total points: 87.5

Penna Luigi Barbera D'Alba N'Giolina 2005
Nose- 6
Taste- 8
Body - 7
Tanin/Acidity - 6
Finish- 8
Integration: The wine tastes a lot better than the nose leads. Headier, almost hot notes of acetone gives a powerful but muddled fruit nose is compensated by a generous, ripe black fruit laden palate. Intermingled with subtle earth notes are present along with softer tannins. Medium to full-bodied frame and it still finishes at 40 seconds. Makes the wines almost riskily interesting. (+2)
Best from: 2008-2014 . Price US$32-US$36
Total points: 87

Penna Luigi Dolcetto D'Alba Galante Superiore 2005
Nose-7.5
Taste-8
Body -8.5
Tanin/Acidity -7
Finish-9
Integration: Woody vanilla beans mingle with dark cherries on the nose, flow seamlessly onto the mid-palate with generous amounts of red cherries and berries. A full bodied frame but softer tannin balance works very well together as the 40 second length of the wine almost makes you loose track of time. A wonderfully delicious number. (+1)
Best from: 2008 -2014. Price US$29- US$
Total points: 91

Penna Luigi Nebbiolo D'Alba Vigito 2005
Nose-8
Taste-8
Body -9
Tanin/Acidity - 9
Finish- 9
Integration: Dried almost raisin berries laced with complex dried woody, herbs make this wine a treat just sniffing it. Hints of fresh earth, red cherry and all spice greet your palate along with a full body loaded with grippingly young tannins. The earth minerals and tannic notes prevail on the finish that takes 50 seconds to fade. A powerhouse of a wine.
Best from 2010-2022. Price US$38-US$42
Total points: 93

Arista Pinot Noir Russian River Valley 2006
Nose-8.5
Taste-8
Body -7
Tanin/Acidity - 7.5
Finish- 7
Integration: Strong aromas of strawberries and ripe cherries with wet earth notes. The fruit notes get stronger on the palate as aromas of red fruit and black cherry reductions with cinnamon dominate the palate. All the while maintaining a bright refreshing balance of tannin and acidity. A medium to full bodied wine that finishes well with focused fruit and a little tea leaf note, which clocked in at 35 seconds.
Best from: 2008-2011 . Price US$32-US$38
Total points: 88

Arista Pinot Noir "Longbow" Russian River Valley 2006
Nose-9
Taste-8
Body -8.5
Tanin/Acidity - 9
Finish- 9
Integration: Powerful aromas of spicy cherry & ripe strawberries greet the nose leading to a muscular framed mid palate. Ripe and racy flavors of sweet blackcherry, plum, cinnamon and hints of nutmeg make this to taste and to savor with a champion like finish of 45 seconds.
Best from: 2008-2014 . Price US$44-US$50
Total points: 93.5

Feraud-Brunel Cotes Du Rhone 2005
Nose-7
Taste-8
Body -8
Tanin/Acidity -7
Finish-6.5
Integration: Heady spice rack notes laced with ripe black fruits. The mid palate transition is a little rough with young tannins mingling with the brooding ripe blackberries and peppery notes.
The tannins releases more fruit near the finish which is between 25-30 seconds. I would be eager to try this wine in a year or two as I believe it holds great potential (+3.5)
Best from: 2010-2018 . Price US$20-US$24
Total points: 90


Feraud-Brunel Chateauneuf Du Pape 2005
Nose- 9
Taste-9.5
Body -9
Tanin/Acidity -9
Finish-9
Integration: A complex mix of ripe fruit and dark savory, aged soy sauce greet your nose as it takes you on a trip of deep layered flavors of dark fruit, leather notes and black pepper served in earthenware. It is as full bodied as it is brilliantly balanced on tannin and acidity. Finishes as powerfully as it started at 45 seconds. Tastes good now but patience will be rewarded.
Best from: 2009-2030. Price US$32-US$38
Total points: 95.5

Pierre Gaillard Cote Rotie 2006
Nose- 10
Taste-9
Body -9
Tanin/Acidity -9.5
Finish-9
Integration: An exotic nose comprising of ripe strawberry, violets, green pandan leaf and roses. A magnificently bodied wine, balanced on a tight rope of elegance and generous mid palate of ripe black fruits now but promises to reveal more in the future as the finish indicates. The finish itself reveals dark earth notes, minerals and ripe fruit as it "shifts time" and clocks in at 40 seconds. A marvelous wine.
Best from: 2012-2028 . Price US$-US$
Total points: 96.5

Frazier Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2003
Nose-8
Taste-8
Body -9
Tanin/Acidity -8
Finish-9
Integration: Spicey Dark cherries and black berries leads into a full bodied, dark fruit, bittersweet chocolate and coffee grounds laden mid palate. The tannins are softer but still assertive and the finish is strong and confidently clocks in at 40 seconds with all the mid palate's flavors carrying on. Very seamless and in its prime.
Best from: 2008-2018 . Price US$58-US$64
Total points: 92

Domaine de Taille Aux Loups " Clos De Venise" Vouvray 2006
Nose-8
Taste-8.5
Body -7
Tanin/Acidity -8
Finish-8
Integration: Toasted nut bread nose with green apple make fro an interesting nose. Riper apples appear on the mid palate along with minerally tones as if one were drinking this wine by a waterfall. Medium bodied with a softer acidic balance that gives it good roundness. A charmingly good wine for Summer
Best from: 2008-2012 . Price US$32-US$36
Total points: 89.5

Now granted there were more wines at this tasting but I found them to be quite forgettable unlike this bunch right here.


*Wine Zen Method of Evaluation:
Assuming the wines tasted are not flawed due to cork taint, heat damage or other obvious defects, 50 points is awarded automatically. The wine is then judged based on its:
a) nose
b) taste
c) body
d) balance of tannin & acidity
e) finish or length (time measured 20 -25 seconds being a standard good finish)

Each tasting dimension is scored from a scale of 1-10. For example, if a wine was more full bodied, it would tend to have a higher score of 8-10. If it were a lighter bodied wine it would receive a lower score of 1-4. Adding up the scores together should give you a total of points out of 100 for a maximum (which very, very rarely happens).

The Twist
Please note that sometimes wines are meant to be leaner or lighter or more elegant or less tannic or acidic. Does that mean they are poorly made, absolutely not. So I have incorporated an extra tasting aspect called Integration. After breaking down the wine to into its tasting components and evaluating them individually, I use this last category to see how all the components work together. Harmony is what I will be looking for. Extra points can be given from this category to make up for shortage of points from the other categories to give a more accurate representation of the wines.

Odds & Ends of Evaluation
Please note that although the wine appearance can be an important aspect. I have found that with modern wine making, the old adage of "you can't judge a book by its cover" rings very like a church bell. A wine can have a gorgeous color but not deliver the quality and vice versa. So when judging the wine, appearance is used to assess if the wine is obviously flawed and if it is worthy of consumption.
In this writers humble opinion, finishes are generally the tell tale signs of a well-made wine. Nose and taste can be muted due to youthfulness of the wine or can be manipulated but you can't hide the flaws of a wine in the finish yet. An abrupt or short finish reveals a shortcoming in fruit quality and like an abrupt conversation can be quite rude. A good finish tends to be a gradual process allowing the wine flavors to fade gently from your palate. The best finishes are not only long and gradual but have what I call "shift time" ability, where the wine makes you forget how long you have been tasting it.